Newer development with contemporary homes, wide streets, and easy access to the causeway and mainland.
New Town represents modern Key West living. Developed in the latter half of the 20th century, this neighborhood features wider streets, newer construction, and contemporary home designs. The area is popular with those seeking modern amenities, open floor plans, and easy access to the Key West International Airport and the causeway to the mainland. Properties include modern single-family homes, townhouses, and condominium communities with resort-style amenities. New Town offers a suburban feel while maintaining island charm.
Price Range
$1.2M - $3.8M
Property Types
Modern Homes, Townhouses, Condo Communities
Lifestyle
Modern, Convenient, Growing
Photo Gallery
Market Insights
Median Price
$1.9M
Days on Market
45-70
Inventory
Moderate (3.6 months)
Price Trend
+8.8% YoY
Walkability Scores
Walk
58
Transit
38
Bike
65
Somewhat Walkable — car-dependent for most errands
Flood Zones & Insurance
FEMA Zones
X, AE (varies)
Insurance Note
Mixed zones. X zones preferred. AE zones require flood insurance. Average annual: $1,400-$4,200
Buyer Intelligence
Architectural Character
Modern CBS and frame construction from the 1960s onward, with many homes fully updated or custom built to current hurricane code standards. No architectural review overlay; owners have maximum flexibility for design, materials, and additions.
Vacation Rentals
Not PermittedShort-term rentals are not permitted in New Town. The area is zoned for annual residential use. This makes New Town a strong market for full-time residents and buy-and-hold investors seeking stable, long-term tenancy.
HOA
NoneMost single-family homes in New Town carry no HOA obligations. Some planned townhome and condo developments have associations with fees in the $200–$600/month range.
Parking
New Town has the most generous parking of any Key West neighborhood — two-car driveways and garages are common. For buyers who drive regularly or own boats and trailers, New Town is the clear practical choice on the island.
Area Schools
Horace O'Bryant Middle School
Poinciana Elementary
Neighborhood Highlights
Newer Construction
Wide Streets
Causeway Access
Growing Area
Modern Amenities
Suburban Feel
Nearby
Restaurants
Denny's Latin Café
2980 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
Attractions
Smathers Beach
2601 S Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
Key West Nature Preserve
S Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
Interested in New Town?
Damian can help you find the perfect property in this neighborhood.
Schedule a Consultation