Casa Marina

A mix of mid-century single-family homes and purpose-built beachfront condominium towers, anchored by Henry Flagler's 1921 Casa Marina Resort. The neighborhood lacks the strict historic oversight of Old Town, giving buyers more flexibility for renovation and new construction.

Vacation rentals shorter than 28 days require a transient BPAS license. Some condominium associations in Casa Marina impose their own minimum-stay rules (30 or 90 days) that are stricter than city requirements — verify with the specific building's docs. As with all Key West transient licenses, confirm the license is transferable to the property's address before relying on rental income projections.

Single-family homes in Casa Marina typically have no HOA. Condominium buildings carry fees of $900–$2,800/month, often including flood and wind insurance, pool and amenity maintenance, and reserves.

Single-family homes typically have one to two off-street spaces. Condo buildings offer assigned garage or surface parking. The area is accessible by bike to most of Key West; a vehicle is useful but not required daily.